15 Comments
User's avatar
TimL's avatar

Gordon knot has been saying this for years https://substack.com/@jackdevanney?r=1mmz89&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=stories&shareImageVariant=blur BTW the US is insanely expensive too. We need South Korea or Chinese cost per GWH. Also at what point does the H&S regs take into consideration frying the planet with CO2 if we don’t sort this out?

Robin Stafford's avatar

I grew up in Cumbria, downwind of Calder Hall (which became Sellafield) and not so far from Chapelcross. Both of course were deeply connected with the military nuclear programme and that may explain a history of dubious safety practices and short cuts. Colleagues in the consulting firm I worked for did some non-technical work at Sellafield and were worried at what they saw, from years of insufficient attention being paid. So perhaps that contributes to an over-reaction in the other direction.

It has also struck me that the nuclear industry has been its own worst enemy, continually experimenting and never settling on a technology that can be proven and repeated. The contrast with other countries is stark.

Gareth Wiltshire's avatar

This article relates explicitly to the nuclear industry. But the approach of endlessly reducing perceived risk to ever lower levels in common across many industries regulated by HSE even where the gross disproportionate test is not used. The endless creep of another layer of protection or a fractionally lower safety target exists.

Even when an economic test is used to prove a step is disproportionate, the result is a not now but look again later requirement from regulators. Giving regulators time to increase the harm values with the potential that next time the disproportionate test won’t be passed.

There is a perception that success in regulators eyes is not an acceptably safe industry, but a list of actions/investment/changes the regulator made industry do.

Sam Dumitriu's avatar

In that piece you suggest that only one of the Nuclear Taskforce had experience of regulation, neglecting the fact that the Chair of the Taskforce ran one of the UK's largest regulators...

Dr Paul Dorfman's avatar

The Chair of the Taskforce is an economist with no experience in nuclear safety regulation.

MICHAEL DAWSON's avatar

You don't address the argument that plant designs incorporate features that can only be justified if one believes that costs can and in some cases should be up to ten times benefits before a cost becomes unreasonable. Or that this is not what the 1974 Act requires or what the main HSE work on ALARP recommends. It's not fair to blame useless contractors and designers if what they are being asked to design and build is over-engineered to the point where a plant is bound to be ridiculously expensive and highly likely to have cost over runs on top of that.

Dr Paul Dorfman's avatar

ALARP - As Low As Reasonably Practicable - is a foundational legal and safety principle in the UK nuclear industry that requires dutyholders to drive down safety and radiation risks to the lowest level possible, balanced against the time, cost, and trouble of further risk-reduction measures.

MICHAEL DAWSON's avatar

Yes, but the argument of the post is that, in practice, risks are being reduced to a degree far beyond what is reasonably practicable, leading to excessive costs. Can you address that, if you disagree?

Dr Paul Dorfman's avatar

The Regulatory Taskforce stated that the UK “has become the most expensive place in the world to build nuclear projects.” And that the planning and regulatory system was “not fit for purpose” What is missing from the Government’s and the Taskforce’s conclusions is any analytical evidence to back up their conclusion that regulation and planning processes need to be deregulated.

https://policybrief.org/briefs/the-government-is-onto-a-false-trail-on-the-uks-nuclear-troubles/